Rahppoye, Hekmat-e Honar

Rahppoye, Hekmat-e Honar

A Mystical Reading of “Drowning of the Bearded Man” Painting Based on Yaqzah (Awakening) Concept from the Perspective of Khwaja Abdullah Ansari

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 PhD in Comparative and Analytical History of Islamic Art, Department of Advanced Art Studies, Faculty of Visual Arts, Tehran University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Professor, Faculty Member, Department of Advanced Art Studies, Faculty of Visual Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
3 Associate Professor, Faculty Member, Department of Painting and Sculpture, Faculty of Visual Arts, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Farid al-Din Attar Neyshaburi is one of the most prolific poets in the Persian language. His works, especially Mantiq al-Tayr, translated into various languages, have many admirers from all over the world. Attar himself acknowledged the sweetness of his words and pen, and he admitted this about Mantiq al-Tayr in specific. On the other hand, Mantiq al-Tayr is one of the most cited texts in literary research, and illustrated manuscripts inspired by it are also among the most cited research works in the field of artistic research. In this research, the Mantiq al-Tayr preserved in the Metropolitan Museum, which is significant due to Kamal al-Din Behzad’s participation and supervision over some of its illustrations, has been studied because of its high-quality artistry and the skillful incorporation of profound mystical points within the realities of everyday life.
On the other hand, Khwaja Abdullah Ansari is one of the great mystics and ascetics of the Khorasan region who, with his monumental work Manazil al-Sa’airin, has provided valuable services in the path of practical spirituality for the seekers of the right way. In this book, he has explained all the stages of the spiritual journey step by step and has scrutinized its dos and don’ts. Using his experiences and beliefs, Abdullah Ansari has presented a specific interpretation of how to achieve Yaqzah (Awakening). Regarding the problem solving, which is a characteristic of the cognitive approach, and also using reasoning, analysis, and division; he has examined the issues and solved the problem of reaching the Yaqzah (Awakening). His goal is to adapt to internal actions such as gratitude for blessings, recognition of shortcomings or, in other words, reviewing one’s own performance and fearing the deceit of others. For this purpose, Abdullah Ansari takes his disciple forward step by step. Therefore, the gradual nature of Islamic mysticism is very important; that is, until a disciple passes through one stage, no other stage will be presented to them.
Yaqzah in its literal sense means “awakening” and stands in contrast to sleep. In Islamic mysticism, it refers to the state of awakening from the slumber of heedlessness, leading to awareness and attention toward the path of divine proximity and spiritual journey toward God. Yaqzah is considered the first light that illuminates the heart of a seeker, marking the beginning of true spiritual life with the radiance of awakening and mindfulness. The spiritual guides regard Yaqzah as the initial condition for entering the realm of spiritual wayfaring, or, in essence, the first station on the path toward God. At the moment of death, all individuals witness the realities of existence and the insignificance of worldly matters, as well as the grandeur of the realms beyond death. They also realize the immense right that the God has over them, a truth that often remains neglected during their lifetime. For a seeker, this awakening occurs at the very first step of their spiritual journey. They become conscious of truths that are typically unveiled for others only at the time of death. This newfound awareness prompts them to value the remaining time in their life and strive earnestly toward attaining closer proximity to God.
Regarding humans as well, if their inner eye opens while they are still in this world, meaning before their departure, the same meaning applies. Imam Ali (peace be upon him) emphasizes this concept, stating that one who possesses an inner moral guide is granted divine protection. He further explains that when God seeks goodness for a servant, He places such an admonisher within his heart. Hence, the catalyst for awakening is this very inner guide, an intrinsic force that calls individuals to move and journey toward God. According to a prominent mystic, Abdullah Ansari, Yaqzah consists of three components: directing the heart’s attention to divine blessings, reflecting on one’s sins, and recognizing the immense value of one’s lifespan.
Applying a descriptive-analytical approach and using library resources (real and virtual), this study has analyzed the subject in a qualitative manner. On this basis, by selecting a painting from the Herat School of Mantiq al-Tayr, “Drowning of the Bearded Man”, it has analyzed and interpreted all the visual and written elements of the painting and examined the relationship between Yaqzah, or awakening, as the first stage in practical mysticism, with the overall story of the painting and the way the characters in the story have operated, which may have been intended by the artist. It should be added that this study aims to address issues that have so far been neglected or that have not been adequately addressed by the researchers.
According to the conducted studies, it was determined that many of the concepts intended by Khwaja Abdullah Ansari are evident among the positive characters in the painting: paying attention to the countless blessings of God, looking forward to God’s blessings, taking a lesson from the people of affliction, recognizing the greatness of God as the most important way to avoid sin, realizing the soul as the root of contamination with major and minor sins, acknowledging God’s punishment in the hereafter as a way to reduce sins, understanding the profit and loss of the days of life, avoiding idleness, and taking advantage of the remaining life and the company of the righteous.
On the other hand, the things that the negative characters in the picture have been drawn to and have suffered loss from are as follows: not paying attention to the inner preacher (reason), not noticing to divine mercy and the unseen, not valuing the truth, not recognizing the self and not acknowledging the promise of the truth, not listening to knowledge, not responding to the calls for respect and not associating with the righteous, not studying sins and not honoring the truth, not realizing the value of the precious life, not making up for what has been lost, not taking a lesson from the plight of those in calamity, and leaving the company of the righteous.
In summary, the study of the painting demonstrates that Behzad and Sultan Ali were highly successful in conveying the message in the depiction of the drowning bearded man. The themes in Attar’s poetry emphasize self-awareness, renouncing worldly attachments, and learning from the plight of those who suffer. Behzad skillfully captures these concepts by portraying a bearded man in the act of drowning, symbolizing neglect of mindfulness and awakening at the beginning of spiritual practice. Sultan Ali further reinforces these ideas by inscribing Attar’s poetry, highlighting the profound meanings embedded within from the perspective of the Elder of Herat. Ultimately, the painting provides an allegorical representation of Attar, brought to life through Behzad’s depiction of the bearded man effectively illustrating a lack of awakening from heedlessness and inattentiveness to the path toward God.
Keywords

Subjects


قرآن کریم.
آذرگون، علی. (1383). نماد در منطق‌الطیر عطار نیشابوری، فصل‌نامه ادبیات فارسی، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی خوی، (2)، 130-151.
آژند، یعقوب. (1387). مکتب نگارگری هرات، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات فرهنگستان هنر.
_________ (1392). نگارگری ایران (پژوهشی در تاریخ نقاشی و نگارگری ایران)، جلد دوم، چاپ دوم، تهران: سازمان مطالعه و تدوین کتب علوم انسانی دانشگاه‌ها.
ابوالخیر، ابوسعید. (2536). یکسو نگریستن (به سوی خدا) و یکسان نگریستن (به سوی خلق خدا)؛ صدماجرا از شیخ ابوسعیدابوالخیر، انتخاب و تلخیص فریدون مشیری، مقدمه جواد نوربخش، چاپ دوم، تهران: صفی‌علیشاه.
اسکندری تُربَقان، ایرج. (1384). هماهنگی طرح و تفکر در آثار کمال‌الدین بهزاد، استاد راهنما: محمدحسین حلیمی، دکتری پژوهش هنر، دانشگاه هنر تهران.
الحکیم، سعاد. (1397). المعجم الصوفی الحکمه فی حدود الکلمه: دانش‌نامه اصطلاحات ابن‌عربی، ترجمه سید ناصر طباطبائی، ویراستار مهناز رئیس‌زاده، چاپ دوم، تهران: مولی.
اشرفی، مقدمه مرجان. (1388). از بهزاد تا رضا عباسی سیر تکاملی مینیاتور در سده دهم و اوایل سده یازدهم هجری، ترجمه نسترن زندی، تهران: مؤسسه تألیف ترجمه و نشر آثار هنری.
انصاری، عبدالله بن محمد. (۱۳۸۹). شرح منازل‌السائرین، شارح اسماعیل منصوری لاریجانی، تهران: سازمان تبلیغات اسلامی و شرکت چاپ و نشر بین الملل.
__________________. (1341). طبقات‌الصوفیه امالی پیر هرات، تصحیح و تعلیق و تحشیه عبدالحی حبیبی قندهاری، افغانستان: وزارت معارف افغانستان.
پاکتچی، احمد. (1392). جریان‌های تصوف در آسیای مرکزی، چاپ اول، تهران: انتشارات بین‌المللی الهدی.
جامی، نورالدین عبدالرحمن. (1378). مثنوی هفت‌اورنگ (سلسله‌الذهب، سلامان و ابسال، تحفه‌الاحرار و سبحه‌الابرار)، مقدمه از اعلاخان افصح‌زاد، تصحیح و تحقیق جابلقا دادعلیشاه و همکاران، جلد اول، چاپ اول، تهران: مرکز مطالعات ایرانی.
حسینی، تکتم (1394)، توصیف، تحلیل و تفسیر هشت نگاره از منطق‌الطیر نسخه موزه متروپولیتن، استاد راهنما: جمال عرب‌زاده، کارشناسی‌ارشد تصویرسازی، دانشگاه هنر تهران.
خیاطیان، قدرت‌الله؛ حمزئیان، عظیم؛ مستجاب‌الدعواتی، سیدعلی. (1399). بررسی تطبیقی زهد از نگاه خواجه‌عبدالله انصاری در منازل‌السائرین و بحیا بن باقودا در الهدایه الی فرائض القلوب، معرفت ادیان،11(1) ،43 -58.
راوندی، قطب‌الدین سعیدبن‌هبه‌الله. (1409ه.ق.). قصص الأنبیاء(ع)، تصحیح و تعلیق غلامرضا عرفانیان یزدی، مشهد: مجمع البحوث الاسلامیه.
زمانی، محبوبه. (1392). منطق‌الطیر به نثر، چاپ سوم، تهران: انتشارات اقبال.
سجادی، سیدجعفر. (1383). فرهنگ اصطلاحات و تعبیرات عرفانی، ویراستار سیدصادق سجادی، چاپ هفتم، تهران: طهوری.
عطار نیشابوری، محمدبن‌ابراهیم. (1390). منطق‌الطیر، چاپ سوم، مبین اندیشه: قم.
کربن، هانری. (1401). واقع‌انگاری رنگ‌ها و علم میزان، مقدمه ترجمه و تحقیق ان‌شاءالله رحمتی، چاپ چهارم، تهران: سوفیا.
_______. (1400). ابن‌سینا و تمثیل عرفانی، مقدمه ترجمه و تحقیق ان‌شاءالله رحمتی، ویراستۀ مصطفی ملکیان، چاپ پنجم، تهران: سوفیا.
کمالی دولت‌آبادی، رسول. (1388). مبانی هنرهای تجسمی ایران مبتنی بر متون دو کتاب مرصادالعباد و گلشن راز، به مثابه تجلی معنا، استاد راهنما: محمد خزائی، پایان نامه کارشناسی ارشد ارتباط تصویری، دانشگاه تربیت مدرس.
محمدی‌آسیابادی، علی. (1386). نظریه ساخت شکنی و ساخت شکنی داستان بِشر پرهیزگار، پژوهش‌های ادب عرفانی، 1(4)،191-216.
میرباقری ‌فرد، سیدعلی‌اصغر؛ مانی، مهنوش. (1398). بررسی یقظه و انتباه در متون منثور عرفانی (تا قرن هفتم) و کاربردهای آن در روان‌شناسی، پژوهش‌نامه عرفان، 10(20)، ص189-210.
میری، محمد. (1398). مقایسۀ تطبیقی آموزه‌های روایی با مبانی عرفان عملی دربارۀ منزل سلوکی یقظه با تأکید بر کتاب منازل‌السائرین، انوار معرفت، 8 (1)، 21-34.
 
Refrences
The Holy Quran.
Abu al-Khair, Abu Sa'id. (1977). Looking One Way (Toward God) and Looking Equally (Toward God's People); One Hundred Stories from Sheikh Abu Sa'id Abu al-Khair. [Yeksou Negaristan be sou-ye Khoda va Yeksaan Negaristan be sou-ye Khalgh-e Khoda]. Selected and summarized by Fereydoun Moshiri, Introduction by Javad Nourbakhsh, 2nd ed., Tehran: Safi-Ali Shah. (In Persian)
Al-Hakim, Suaad. (2018). Al-Mu'jam al-Sufi: Al-Hikmah fi Hudud al-Kalimah. [Al-Mu'jam al-Sufi: Al-Hikmah fi Hudud al-Kalimah]. 2nd ed., translated by Seyed Naser Tabatabaei, edited by Mahnaz Raeeszadeh. Tehran: Mola. (In Persian)
Ansari, Abdulah Ibn Mohammad. (2010). Commentary on Manazil al-Sa'irin. [Sharh-e Manazil al-Sa'irin]. Annotated by Esmaeil Mansouri Larijani. Tehran: Sazman-e Tablighat-e Eslami. (In Persian)
____________. (1962). Tabaqat al-Sufiyya: Amali Pir-e Herat. [Tabaghat Al-Soufiyeh Emaali-e Pir-e Herat]. Edited, annotated, and commented by Abd Al-Hay Ghandehari. Afghanistan: Wezarat-e Maaref-e Afghanistan. (In Persian)
Ashrafi, Moghadameh Marjan. (2009). From Behzad to Reza Abbasi, the Evolution of Miniatures in the 10th & Early 11th AH. [Az Behzad ta Reza Abbasi Seyr-e Takamol-e miniature dar sadeh-e 10 ta Awayel-e sadeh-e 11 Hijri]. Translated by Nastaran Zandi, Tehran: Moaseseh-e Talif Tarjomeh va Nashr-e Aathaar-e Honari]. (In Persian)
Attar Neyshaburi, Mohammad Ebrahim. (2011). the Conference of the Birds. [Mantiq al-Tayr]. 3rd ed. Qom: Mobin Andisheh. (In Persian)
Azargun, Ali. (2004). Symbol in Attar Neyshaburi's Mantiq-al-Tayr. [Namaad dar Mantiq- al-Tayr Attar Neyshabouri]. Fasl-Naameh Adabiyat-e Farsi, Khoy Islamic Azad University, (2), 130-151. (In Persian)
Azhand, Yaqoub. (2008). the School of Herat Painting. [Maktab-e Negargari Herat]. Tehran: Farhangestan-e Honar. (In Persian)
_____________.(2013). Iranian Painting (A Study on the History of Iranian Painting and Drawing). [Negargari-ye Iran]. Vol. 2, 2nd Ed., Tehran: SAMT. (In Persian)
Bahari‎, Ebadollah.‫ (1996). Bihzad: master of persian painting, foreword by Annemarie schimmel, London: I.B.TaurisPublishers.  
Barry, Michael A. (2004). ‏Figurative art in Medieval Islam and the Riddle of Bihzad of Herat (1465-1535), ‏‫ Paris: Flammarion.
Corbin, Henry. (2022). Realism of colors and the science of Mizaan. [Waghe-Engari-e Rangha va Elm-e Mizaan]. Introduction, translation, and commentary by Enshaallah Rahmati, 4th ed. Tehran: Sophia. (In Persian)
__________. (2021). Ibn Sina and mystical allegory. [Ibn-e Sina va Tamsil-e Erfani]. Introduction, translation, and research by Enshaallah Rahmati, edited by Mostafa Malekian, 5th ed., Tehran: Sophia. (In Persian)
Eskandari Torabqan, Iraj. (2005). the coordination of design and thought in the works of Kamal al-Din Behzad. Doctoral Dissertation in Art Research, University of Tehran, Faculty of Art. Supervisor: M. H. Halimi. (In Persian)
Hosseini, Toktam. (2015). Description, analysis, and interpretation of eight illustrations from the "Mantiq al-Tayr" manuscript in the Metropolitan Museum Collection (Master's thesis). Tehran University of Art. Supervisor: Jamal Arabzadeh. (In Persian)
Jami, Nour al-Din Abd al-Rahman. (1998). Seven Thrones (Silsal al-Dhahab, Salaman and Absal, Tohfat al-Ahrar and Subhat al-Abrar). [Haft Awrang]. Introduction by Aalaakhan Afsahzad, edited and researched by Jabolqa Dadalishah and colleagues, Vol. 1, 1st Ed. Tehran: Markaz-e Motaleat-e Irani. (In Persian)
Kamada, Yumiko. “The Mantiq al-tair (Language of the Birds) of 1487.” In Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History. New York: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, 2000–. http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/mant/hd_mant.htm  (June 2010) (Accessed Feb. 2023).
Kamali Dolatabadi, Rasoul. (2009). Fundamentals of Iranian Visual Arts Based on the Texts of the Two Books, Mersad al-Ebad and Gulshan Raz, as a Manifestation of Meaning, Supervisor: Mohammad Khazaee, Master's Thesis, Tarbiyat Modares University. (In Persian)
Khayatian, Ghodratollah, Hamzaeian, Azim, & Mostajab-aldawati, Seyed Ali. (2020). A comparative study of asceticism from the perspective of Khwaja Abdullah Ansari in Manazel al-Saerin and Bahya Ibn Baquda in Al-Hidaya ila Fara'id al-Qulub. [Barresi tatbighi ​​zohd az negah-e Khwaja Abdullah Ansari dar Manazel al-Saerin va Bahiya ben Baghouda dar Alhedayeh elaa faraez-Algholoub]. Marifat-e Adyan, 11(1), 43-58. https://doi.org/10.30495/jrs.2022.66926.10759 (In Persian)
Kia, Chad. (2019). Art, Allegory and the Rise of Shiism in Iran, 1487–1565, Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
________. (2006). Is the Bearded Man Drowning? Picturing the Figurative in a Late-Fifteenth-Century Painting from Herat. Muqarnas, (23)1, 85-105. https://doi.org/10.1163/22118993_02301005
________. (2009). Image, text, and the discourse of Sufism in Iran, 1487-1565, Ph.D. Dissertation, field title:?, Supervisor: ?, Adviser: Hamid Dabashi, Columbia University ProQuest Dissertations & Theses, UMI 3388420.
Miri, Mohammad. (2019). A comparative analysis of narrative teachings and the foundations of practical mysticism regarding the spiritual station of awakening, with an emphasis on the book Manāzel al-Sā'erīn. [moghayse-ye tatbighi ​​amuzehhaye ravayi ba mobani Erafan-e Amali darbareh manzel-e solouki yaqzah ba taakid bar ketab-e Manazil al-Sa'irin]. Anvār-e Ma'refat, 8(1), 21-34. https://erfani.nashriyat.ir/en/node/151 (In Persian)
Mirbagheri-Fard, Seyed Ali Asghar. & Mani, Mehnoush. (2019). an examination of wakefulness and awareness in mystical prose texts up to the 7th century and their applications in psychology. [Barresi yaqzah va Entebah dar motoun manthur Erfani ta gharn-e 7 Hijri va karbordha-ye an dar ravanshenasi]. Pajoheshnameh Erfan, 10(20), 189-210. (In Persian)
Mohammadi-Asyabadi, Ali. (2007). Deconstruction theory and the deconstruction of the story of abstemious Beshr. [Nazariyeh-e Sakhtshekani va Sakhtshekani dar Dastan-e Beshr-e Parhizkar]. Pajouheshhay-e Aadab-e Erfani. 1(4), 191-216. (In Persian)
Pakatchi, Ahmad. (2013). Sufi Currents in Central Asia. [Jaryanhay-e Tasawof dar Asiya-ye Markazi]. 1st ed., Tehran: Al-Hoda. (In Persian)
Rawandi, Qutb al-Din Saeed ibn Hebatullah. (1988). Stories of the Prophets. [Ghesas Al-Anbiya]. Corrected and annotated by Gholamreza Erfaniyan Yazdi, Mashhad: Majma' al-Bohouth al-Islamiyyah. (In Persian)
Sajjadi, Seyed  Jafar. (2004). A dictionary of mystical terms and expressions. [Farhang-e Estelahat va Tabirat-e Erfani]. Edited by Seyed Sadegh Sajjadi. 7th ed. Tehran: Tahoori. (In Persian)
Subtelny, Maria Eva. (1986). A Taste for the Intricate: The Persian Poetry of the Late Timurid Period, Zeitschrift der Deutschen Morgenländischen Gesellschaft (Journal of the German Oriental Society), (136)1, 56-79. https://www.jstor.org/stable/43377395
Zamani, Mahboobeh. (2013). Mantiq-al-Tayr in Prose. [Mantiq-al-Tayr be Nathr]. 3rd ed., Tehran: Iqbal. (In Persian)
URL1: https://www.metmuseum.org/ (Accessed Oct. 2018 - Sep. 2024)
URL2: https://www.bl.uk/ (Accessed Oct. 2018 - Sep. 2024)
URL3: https://dehkhoda.ut.ac.ir (Accessed Oct. 2018 - Sep. 2024)
URL4: https://fa.wikifeqh.ir/ (Accessed Oct. 2018 - Sep. 2024)
URL5: https://fa.wikipedia.org/wiki/(Accessed Apr. 2023 - Jun. 2023)
URL6: https://fa.wikishia.net/view/ (Accessed Oct. 2018 - Sep. 2024)
 
Volume 4, Issue 2 - Serial Number 7
September 2025
Pages 7-22

  • Receive Date 16 January 2025
  • Revise Date 09 March 2025
  • Accept Date 08 April 2025