Rahppoye, Hekmat-e Honar

Rahppoye, Hekmat-e Honar

The Phenomenology of Experiencing the Unseen (al-Ghayb) in the Architecture of the Holy Mosque of Jamkaran

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Philosophy of Art, Faculty of Theoretical Sciences and Advanced Studies in Art, Iran University of Art, Tehran, Iran.
2 PhD student in Islamic Architecture, Department of Architecture, Faculty of Technology, Qom University,Qom, Iran.
10.22034/rph.2026.2093177.1236
Abstract
The experience of encountering a reality that transcends both sensory perception and rational cognition—a reality understood as “hidden” or “unseen” (al-ghayb)— is among the most complex and profound dimensions of religious life, particularly as it is mediated through the architecture of sacred spaces.
The Sacred Mosque of Jamkaran, understood in Twelver Shiʿi thought as an intermediate space between mosque (masjid) and shrine (ḥaram), transcends the function of a purely devotional site. Rather, it has been constituted as an ontological axis rooted in the profound belief in the hidden presence of Imam al-Zaman (the Twelfth Imam).
The phenomenology of Jamkaran Mosque, in which a lived encounter with the Hidden Imam lies at the core of the pilgrims’ experience, shares affinities with broader patterns observed in sacred sites throughout the world. At Jamkaran, al-ghayb is not merely a belief lodged in the minds of pilgrims; rather, it approaches the realm of lived experience through a sacred process.
This experience is shaped by the convergence of elements such as the orientation of the building, the absence of a zārīḥ, the interplay between collective supplication and silence, and the communal rituals of the pilgrims. Here, the presence of the Unseen is not manifested in material form; rather, it reveals itself as a felt presence within the atmosphere of the space, the movements of the pilgrims, and the sounds of ritual.
This research seeks to address the fundamental question of how the architecture of this mosque enables the pilgrim to experience the presence of the Unseen within a lived spatial encounter. Methodologically, the study adopts a descriptive-analytical approach informed by contemporary phenomenology, particularly the aesthetics of atmosphere.
It is based on library research and the documentary analysis of relevant scholarly and primary sources. These include Qurʾānic texts and theological exegeses concerning the concept of al-ghayb; Islamic philosophical and mystical (ʿirfānī) works, particularly those of Ibn ʿArabī, Mullā Ṣadrā, and Suhrawardī; and major theories in the philosophy of religious experience, including Rudolf Otto’s concept of the numinous, Mircea Eliade’s notion of hierophany, and Gernot Böhme’s theory of atmosphere as a sensory language for perceiving the Unseen.
The analysis is conducted through a phenomenological hermeneutics of meaning. Avoiding surveys, interviews, and quantitative measurement, this study seeks to access the existential structure of the experience of the Unseen at Jamkaran Mosque from within the phenomena themselves, and to articulate that structure within an integrated theoretical framework combining Islamic thought and contemporary phenomenological philosophy.
Within the theoretical framework of this research, the concept of al-ghayb is examined as a supra-empirical and non-sensory reality through four complementary and interrelated conceptual levels.
First, from within Islamic thought, where al-ghayb is understood not as mere absence or non-existence, but as a degree of reality whose apprehension requires an existential and epistemological journey. Second, from the perspective of the phenomenology of religious experience, particularly Rudolf Otto’s theory of the numinous, which describes the immediate, non-mediated apprehension of the Holy as mysterium tremendum et fascinans—a mystery that is at once awe-inspiring and captivating.
Third, within the domain of sacred space, drawing upon Mircea Eliade’s concept of hierophany and Victor Turner’s notion of liminality, which together present the sacred place as a liminal threshold between the seen and unseen worlds. Fourth, through Gernot Böhme’s theory of atmosphere, which elucidates the sensory language of the presence of the Unseen in architecture through elements such as light, silence, orientation, and the interaction between the perceiving subject and the environment.
This integrated framework makes it possible for al-ghayb—though in essence beyond sensory perception and conceptual representation—to be experienced as an accessible reality within the pilgrim’s consciousness, through the interconnection of these four levels of meaning.
Based on these theoretical foundations, Jamkaran Mosque was systematically analyzed. The findings reveal that the mosque is structured by three sacred atmospheres: the atmosphere of the sacred, understood as a space between mosque and shrine; the atmosphere of expectation (intizār), actualized through liminality; and the atmosphere of the Unseen (al-ghayb), manifested through the absence of a zārīḥ and related spatial elements.
The results show that the presence of the Unseen at Jamkaran Mosque is not produced through a material or tangible symbol such as a zārīḥ. Rather, it emerges through the Imam’s corporeal absence, the orientation of the building, its symbolic qibla-centered configuration, the rhythm of supplication and prayer, light, silence, and the synchronized movement of the pilgrims.
In essence, this spatial structure creates an architectural condition in which the pilgrim does not merely believe in the Unseen but experiences it as a living, direct, and deeply felt reality.
Drawing upon Böhme’s (2015) theory of atmosphere, the Sacred Mosque of Jamkaran was analyzed through three atmospheres—the sacred, expectation, and the Unseen—to show how each is perceived within the domain of lived experience.
Existentially, Jamkaran Mosque occupies an intermediate position between mosque and shrine. Among mosques in the Islamic world, it is regarded as having the closest spiritual proximity to al-Masjid al-Ḥarām. Its attribution to the Imam of the Age transforms it into a sanctuary of the living and present Imam, elevating it to the status of a ḥaram-ziyāratgāh, a shrine-place of pilgrimage.
This sacred place functions as a threshold that leads the pilgrim toward a mode of presence beyond sensory perception. The hidden presence of Imam al-Zaman at this site is constituted not through material manifestation but through absence. This bodily absence corresponds fully with the concept of tajallī al-ghayb (the manifestation of the Unseen) in Ibn ʿArabī’s philosophy and Mullā Ṣadrā’s Transcendent Theosophy (al-ḥikma al-mutaʿāliya), wherein it constitutes a necessary condition for the deeper theophany of the Absolute Essence.
The architectural space of Jamkaran, through elements such as the turquoise color of the dome (symbolizing heaven and hope), the simplified qibla-oriented spatial configuration (evoking the austerity of the Kaʿba), the rhythm of collective supplications (Duʿāʾ al-Nudba, Duʿāʾ al-ʿAhd, Duʿāʾ al-Faraj), and the silence accompanying the pilgrims’ movement, generates an atmosphere that, as Böhme (2015) explains, produces “spheres of presence” within material absence.
Within this atmosphere, the pilgrim’s experience is existential and felt. The “sorrow of separation” is no longer merely a remembrance of absence; rather, it becomes a living experience of a presence that, as Otto describes, is simultaneously awe-inspiring and captivating.
Consequently, it can be concluded that Jamkaran Mosque is not merely a place of worship but an “expanded zārīḥ”: a space in which the entire architectural body becomes the embodiment of the Sacred, housing within itself expectation and the unseen presence—the eternal theophany of the living and present Imam.
This finding is not a subjective proposition but a phenomenological insight arising from the intrinsic structure of the pilgrim’s experience in this space. Here, bodily absence provides the condition for spiritual presence, and non-seeing becomes the condition for true seeing.
Thus, the architecture of Jamkaran does not simply contain belief; it actively mediates, through spatial and ritual means, the pilgrim’s encounter with an unseen reality that remains irreducible to material representation within the horizon of sacred experience itself.
This is the very reality emphasized by Muslim mystics (ʿurafāʾ): that it is accessible only through direct experiential witnessing (al-shuhūd). By reconstructing the inner structure of that experience through a phenomenological method, this research has sought to approach its description as faithfully as possible.
Keywords
Subjects

Unified alphabetical list of Persian-language and original English-language references
Adibzadeh, Bahman; Aminpour, Ahmad; Razjouyan, Mahmoud; Jalilzadeh Mohammadi, Fatemeh. (2015). Architecture as a witness to the unseen: An approach to the unseen in Iranian mosque architecture. [memari-ye shahedan-e gheyb: ruykard-e gheybi dar memari-ye masajed-e Iran]. Second International Congress on Religious Culture and Thought, Qom. https://civilica.com/doc/548327 (In Persian)
Alipour, Younes. (2017). Jamkaran Mosque hosts 350,000 pilgrims per week. [masjed-e Jamkaran dar hafte mizban-e 350 hezar zaer ast]. Mehr News Agency, News ID 3991405; retrieved 29 May 2017. https://mehrnews.com/xHWqg (In Persian)
Almond, P. C. (2017). Rudolf Otto: An introduction to his philosophical theology. UNC Press Books.
Amini, Amirhossein; Soltanzadeh, Hossein. (2017). The atmosphere of space in phenomenology as a space without surface. [atmosfer-e faza dar padidarshenasi be-masabe-ye faza-ye bedun-e sath]. Modiriyat-e Shahri, 49, 469–487. (In Persian)
Arshad Riahi, Ali; Iranpour, Parvin. (2010). Ways of knowing the unseen world according to Mulla Sadra and Allameh Tabatabaei. [tariqe-ye shenakht-e alam-e gheyb az nazar-e Molla Sadra va Allameh Tabatabaei]. Kheradnameh-ye Sadra, 59, 85–98. https://ttr.ir/nnh65k (In Persian)
Burckhardt, Titus. (1986). Islamic art: Language and expression. [honar-e eslami: zaban va bayan]. Trans. Masoud Rajabnia. Tehran: Entesharat-e Soroush. https://ttr.ir/k962ww (In Persian)
Böhme, G. (2015). The aesthetics of atmospheres. London: Routledge.
Corbin, Henry. (1975). The Kaaba and its spiritual mystery according to Qazi Said Qomi. [khane-ye Kabe va raz-e manavi-ye an az nazar-e Qazi Said Qomi]. Maaref-e Eslami, 23, 21–27. http://noo.rs/rZ3FE (In Persian)
Danesharani, Zahra; Sattari Sarbanqoli, Hassan. (2018). Reinterpreting symbols of the promised savior on Kashan luster tiles. [bazkhani-ye barkhi namadha-ye monji-ye mowud dar kashiha-ye zarrinfam-e Kashan]. Asr-e Adineh, 27, 22–45. http://noo.rs/BB1gO (In Persian)
Eliade, Mircea. (2015). Sacred architecture and symbolism. [memari-ye qodsi va ramzpardazi]. In Myth and symbol in Mircea Eliade's thought (Vol. 6), trans. Jalal Sattari. Tehran: Nashr-e Markaz. (In Persian)
Fahimi, Reza; Aghahosseini, Hossein; Nasr Esfahani, Mohammadreza. (2012). The concept of manifestation and its types from Ibn Arabi's perspective. [barrasi-ye mafhum-e tajalli va anvae an az didgah-e Ibn Arabi]. Adabiyat-e Erfani, (6), 100–120. (In Persian)
Hassanpour Lamer, Saeed; Nejad Ebrahimi, Ahad; Vandshoari, Ali. (2022). Reinterpreting motifs and architectural ornamentation of historic Masuleh through the concepts of expectation, the savior, and Mahdism. [bazkhani-ye noqoush va arayeha-ye memari-ye shahr-e tarikhi-ye Masuleh bar mabna-ye mafahim-e entezar monji va mahdaviyat]. Asr-e Adineh, 36, 7–31. http://noo.rs/276uv (In Persian)
Hemmati, Homayoun. (1998). Rudolf Otto and the book The Idea of the Holy. [Rudolf Otto va ketab-e mafhum-e amr-e qodsi]. Ketab-e Mah-e Din, (12), 23–26. https://ttr.ir/tidlax (In Persian)
Ibn al-Athir al-Jazari, Mubarak ibn Muhammad. (n.d.). The ultimate guide to uncommon words in hadith and traditions. [al-nihaya fi gharib al-hadith wa al-athar]. Qom: Moassese-ye Matbuati-ye Esmaeilian. (In Persian)
Ibn Arabi, Muhammad ibn Ali; Afifi, Abu al-Ala. (1991). The bezels of wisdom (Vol. 2). [fusūs al-hikam]. Tehran: Al-Zahra. (In Persian)
Ibn Faris, Abu al-Husayn Ahmad. (1989 [1410 AH]). Dictionary of language standards. [mojam maqayis al-logha]. Qom: Entesharat-e Daftar-e Tablighat-e Eslami-ye Howzeh-ye Elmiyeh-ye Qom. (In Persian)
Jalilzadeh Mohammadi, Fatemeh; Adibzadeh, Bahman; Aminpour, Ahmad. (2021). An introspective examination of Isfahan Jameh Mosque architecture with an emphasis on unseen concepts in Persian ghazals by Hafez and Rumi. [barrasi-ye darunnegarane-ye memari-ye Masjed-e Jame-e Esfahan ba takid bar mafahim-e gheybi-ye ghazaliyat-e farsi]. Pazhuheshha-ye Memari-ye Eslami, 9(2), 19–38. (In Persian)
Jami, Abd al-Rahman; Ibn Arabi, Muhammad ibn Ali; Ashtiyani, Jalal al-Din; Chittick, William C.. (1991). Critique of the texts in explanation of the inscription of the bezels. [naqd al-nosus fi sharh naqsh al-fosus]. Tehran: Pazhuheshgah-e Olum-e Ensani va Motaleat-e Farhangi. (In Persian)
Jawhari, Ismail ibn Hammad. (1989 [1410 AH]). The crown of language and the authentic Arabic lexicon. [taj al-logha va sihah al-arabiya]. Beirut: Dar al-Ilm lil-Malayin. (In Persian)
Khakrand, Shokrollah. (2016). The concept and status of sanctuary in Islamic culture. [mafhum va jaygah-e haram dar farhang-e eslami]. Farhang-e Razavi, 14, 97–122. https://doi.org/10.1001.1.23452560.1395.4.14.5.8 (In Persian)
Kiani Achgardi, Neda; Shirnejadi, Hatem. (2021). Explaining the manifestation of the myth of sacred place in museums based on Mircea Eliade's views. [tabyin-e tajalli-ye osture-ye makan-e moqaddas dar nahad-e muze ba tekye bar ara-ye Mircea Eliade]. Graphic-e Naqqashi, (4), 92–105. (In Persian)
Mahdipour, Ali Akbar. (2002). The mirror of expectation: Jamkaran Sacred Mosque. [ayene-ye entezar-e Masjed-e Moqaddas-e Jamkaran]. Mokatebe va Andisheh, 14, 139–160. (In Persian)
Majlesi, Mohammad Baqer ibn Mohammad Taqi. (1989). Seas of lights (Vol. 111). [bihar al-anwar]. Beirut: Dar Ihya al-Turath al-Arabi. (In Persian)
Mohammad Hashemi, Abdollah. (2016). The culture of expectation as a foundation for the realization of a Mahdist society. [farhang-e entezar zaminehsaz-e tahaqqoq-e jamee-ye mahdavi]. Payam, (118), 22–38. (In Persian)
Moradi, Mahin. (2024). The scope of Quranic knowledge based on verse 59 of Surah al-Anam (With Him are the keys to the unseen). [qalamro-ye danesh-e Quran bar mabna-ye aye-ye 59 sure-ye Anam]. Motaleat-e Quran va Hadith-e Safineh, 84, 191–204. http://noo.rs/xfJDi (In Persian)
Mostafid, Hamidreza. (2022). Reflections on the meaning of belief in the unseen in the Quran. [derangi dar manaye iman be gheyb dar Quran]. Motaleat-e Quran va Hadith-e Safineh, 77, 174–182. http://noo.rs/xWDWk (In Persian)
Motahhari Elhami, Mojtaba. (2005). Religious art in Burckhardt's thought. [honar-e dini dar araye Burckhardt]. Khiyal, (16), 140–149. (In Persian)
Nadimi, Hadi; Hosseini (Zharfa), Seyyed Abolqasem; Meghdadi, Zahra; Navvab, Seyyed Mohammad Hossein. (2022). Liminality in pilgrimage architecture: The effects of pilgrimage rituals on the architecture of the Razavi shrine, emphasizing entrance thresholds. [astanegi dar memari-ye ziarat: barrasi-ye ertebat va tasir-e manasek-e ziarat bar kalbod-e memari-ye haram-e Razavi]. Pazhuheshnameh-ye Hajj va Ziarat, 18, 105–144. https://ttr.ir/q5rta3 (In Persian)
Noghrekar, Abdolhamid. (2013). The Kaaba as a stem cell for designing desirable places of worship: Strategic principles and practical solutions. [khane-ye Kabe: solul-e bonyadi dar tarahi-ye niyayeshgahha-ye matlub]. Pazhuheshha-ye Memari-ye Eslami, 1, 25–42. (In Persian)
Otto, R. (1924). The idea of the holy: An inquiry into the non-rational factor in the idea of the divine and its relation to the rational (J. W. Harvey, Trans.; revised with additions). London: Oxford University Press.
Owjaqi, Naser al-Din. (2018). Conceptual study of the unseen in the Quran based on Allameh Tabatabaei's views. [mafhumshenasi-ye gheyb dar Quran ba tekye bar ara-ye Allameh Tabatabaei]. Motaleat-e Qurani, 34, 33–48. https://www.noormags.ir/view/fa/articlepage/1388576 (In Persian)
Partow, Shideh; Nowruzbarazjani, Vida; Mirshahzadeh, Shervin. (2021). Reading the factors affecting the formation of spatial atmosphere in contemporary mosques using grounded theory. [khanesh-e avamel-e moasser bar sheklgiri-ye atmosfer-e fazayi-ye masajed-e moaser ba tekye bar nazariye-ye dadeh-bonyad]. Bagh-e Nazar, 18(95), 5–18. https://sid.ir/paper/388881/fa (In Persian)
Partow, Shideh; Nowruzbarazjani, Vida; Mirshahzadeh, Shervin. (2022). Examining factors affecting the perception of spirituality in mosque spaces: A case study of six contemporary Tehran mosques. [barrasi-ye moallefeha-ye tasirgozar bar edrak-e hess-e manaviyat dar faza-ye masajed]. Motaleat-e Shahr-e Irani-Eslami, 12(48), 29–40. https://sid.ir/paper/1056969/fa (In Persian)
Pérez-Gómez, Alberto. (2017). Architectural space: Meaning as presence and representation. [faza-ye memari: mana be-masabe-ye hozur va baznamayi]. In S. Holl et al., Questions of perception: Phenomenology of architecture. Trans. Ali Akbari & Mohammadamin Sharifian. Tehran: Parham Naghsh. https://b2n.ir/550351 (In Persian)
Qayyumi Bidhendi, Mehrdad. (2011). Essays on the foundations and history of architecture and art. [goftarhayi dar mabani va tarikh-e memari va honar]. Tehran: Entesharat-e Elmi va Farhangi. (In Persian)
Rahmani, Bashir. (2024). The mosque and its various functions. [masjed va karkardha-ye mokhtalef-e an]. Afaq-e Olum-e Ensani, 8(84), 1–16. http://noo.rs/HTpTI (In Persian)
Ries, Julien. (2015). History of religions, phenomenology, and hermeneutics. [tarikh-e adyan: padidarshenasi va hermeneutik]. In Myth and symbol in Mircea Eliade's thought (Vol. 6), trans. Jalal Sattari. Tehran: Nashr-e Markaz. (In Persian)
Sadafi, Mehdi. (2015). An examination of the meaning of the unseen world in Islamic philosophy and mysticism. [barrasi-ye manaye alam-e gheyb dar falsafeh va erfan-e eslami]. Bavar-e Falsafi, 4, 103–107. http://noo.rs/BdsYd (In Persian)
Safi Khani, Samareh; Safiri, Khadijeh. (2019). A study of Jamkaran Mosque pilgrims' interpretations of the doctrine of occultation. [motalee-ye tafasir-e ziaratkonandegan-e masjed-e Jamkaran az amuze-ye gheibat]. Jamee-Pazhuheshi-ye Farhangi, 2(32), 29–54. http://noo.rs/11TqS (In Persian)
Shafaei, Reza. (2007). The musical relationship between prayer and mosque architecture. [rabete-ye musiqayi-ye namaz va bana-ye masjed]. Ketab-e Mah-e Honar, 103–104, 14–21. https://ttr.ir/ogo9k8 (In Persian)
Taghvai, Vida. (2011). The Kaaba: From attaining shape to the presence of form. [Kabe az hosul-e shekl ta hozur-e surat]. Motaleat-e Honar-e Eslami, 15, 7–20. https://ttr.ir/1xgbho (In Persian)
Taherzadeh, Asghar. (2003). How the awaited Imam is present in existence. [nahve-ye hozur-e Hazrat-e Hojjat dar hasti]. Mokatebe va Andisheh, 17, 135–156. http://noo.rs/q3nxH (In Persian)
Talebi, Abutorab; Salami, Ahmad. (2016). Popular religiosity: Examining petitions to the Jamkaran well from petitioners' perspectives. [dindari-ye ammiyane: vakavi-ye arizehnevisi baraye chah-e Jamkaran az manzar-e arizehnevisan]. Olum-e Ejtemai, 72, 71–108. http://noo.rs/Wd82x (In Persian)
Tarbiyatjou, Mohammadali; Eslami, Seyyed Gholamreza. (2018). Dialogue between humans and sacred places: On the audience's role in understanding place sanctity. [mokaleme-ye ensan va makan-e moqaddas: jestari bar naqsh-e mokhatab dar fahm-e qedasat-e makan]. Hoviyat-e Shahr, 12(35), 65–74. https://sid.ir/paper/154568/fa (In Persian)
Tasht Zarrin, Sakineh Khatoun. (2016). Characteristics of the savior and the era of emergence from the perspective of Jamkaran pilgrims. [vizhegiha-ye monji va dowran-e zohur az manzar-e zaeran-e Jamkaran]. Pazhuheshha-ye Mahdavi, (19), 87–110. (In Persian)
Turner, Victor; Turner, Edith. (2021). A processual approach to culture: Victor Turner's anthropological theory. [ruykard-e farayandi be farhang: nazariye-ye ensanshenakhti-ye Victor Turner]. Trans. Maryam Aghazadeh et al. Tehran: Tisa Saghr-e Mehr. (In Persian)
Turner, V. (1982). Religious celebrations. In V. Turner (Ed.).
Vakili, Hadi; Jafari Amanabadi, Hadi. (2017). Rudolf Otto: The substance of the holy and its forms. [Rudolf Otto: madde-ye amr-e qodsi va surathaye an]. Pazhuheshnameh-ye Erfan, (17), 209–230. (In Persian)
Volume 5, Issue 2 - Serial Number 9
October 2026
Pages 83-96

  • Receive Date 02 July 2026
  • Revise Date 08 August 2026
  • Accept Date 14 August 2026